So I tested out the Pumpkin Butter, and here's my impressions: I like this thing, a lot.
I normally run all my gain/distortion pedals with a volume pedal after them, so that I can prevent my modulation pedals from clipping. (Less of an issue now that I have better modulation, but that's how I roll.)
I put the pumpkin butter farther in the chain, with the delays, because it was easy to wire it in there. And at first I didn't think I was getting any fuzz out of it.. Maybe just a little drive? The I realized I had the volume pedal down and was giving it maybe 15% signal. I struck a chord and swelled the volume up. There's the fuzz! Cool!
What did I learn there? This thing is highly reactive to the signal driving it.
I haven't really had an IC muff before, but I've seen plenty of demos and played lots of other fuzzes. I think Mr. Wire was correct in setting the gain internally. Give it a try and see how you like it. The reason is: just as rolling back the volume cleans it up into overdrive territory, driving the pumpkin butter with something else really opens up the fuzz of this thing. In particular, it seemed to like my And Aardvarks the most (which was set up as an overdrive, gain all the way up and volume way above unity.). Sustain was killer. It also stacked well with my fuzzes, as a sort of "solo channel" on them. The only issue here is that the background noise factor comes into play, but I assume that's because there's so many gain stages in play, and nothing is wrong with the Pumpkin Butter.
Should you buy one? Yes!
I kinda wish I had got one for myself. Oh we'll. I think my brother is going to really dig it. He's had a NYc (black) muff that we did a Creamy Dreamer mod on, and he's gone through a lot of the Devi Ever pedals that I handed down to him, but I don't think he's ever had an IC muff-style fuzz, and I think it'll suit his current setup well.
Two thumbs up on this pedal!
