Your KEEPER pedals!

[MrNovember]

Pretty much all of my pedals have become keepers
Primarily, any of my SS/BS, Dwarfcrafts and Fairfields
Any of the others I could probably find some kind of a replacement

[backwardsvoyager]

EHX Freeze - sure it's not boutique but it adds a whole new dimension to your playing, definitely a keeper as a creative tool.
Subdecay Baby Quasar - only recently acquired but definitely the most usable phaser I've ever played.
Mellowtone Wolf Computer - has a wolf on it, obviously too badass to sell.

HAH well i no longer own any of these pedals...

i can say for sure that the Boss RV-3 and Mini are KEEPERS now, though. there are other contenders but those two are tits.

[KaosCill8r]

Big box ri rat. That was the fuzz that sparked my fuzz love. My DIY fingerprint clone. Well any of my DIY fuzz pedal clones for that matter. Actually any of my fuzz pedals full stop. You can never have too much FUZZZZ!

[frigid midget]

For me it's the cheapest ones on my board, by far: Boss FZ-2 and CE-2. Not that they'll never get swapped, I just don't see myself selling em, but they might leave the board for something else for a while...

Other than that: Crowther Hotcake. Just so juicy and thick on mid gain settings. Combined with some amp dirt or fuzz it's pure bliss, totally blows my rat away.

Other than that: My newish Dr Scientist The elements is already becoming my main go-to dirt. It's like my grab and go pedal if I wanna run out for a quick jam with a couple buddies and I can't or don't want to haul around my big ass board. No matter what the task is, the elements will be able to handle anything from brootz to stoner to mellow indie stuff and everything in between. Amazingly good sounding and so damn versatile for such a compact little pedlol...

[zRobertez]

Oh I want to add Sparkle Motion. That's a definite need to have forever one

[skullservant]

To quote myself from 2012:

Tall Font Sovtek Muff
El Capistan
Point to Point Super Hard On Clone
BAT Black Forest

Tall Font is still here, El Cap (although it is my 3rd) is glued to my gig board, and I've got a SHO clone on my home board. No more Black Forest, Rangemasters are filling my needs there.

Some other pedals that won't be moving:

PolyTune Mini Nior
Montreal Assembly Goodbye 24 v1
DOD Buzz Box
Dr. Scientist BitQuest
SSBS Fuck
Turbo Rat clone with 308, finally tweaked a Rat to my liking.
Super Duper clone
Way Huge Fat Sandwich
EHX Holy Grail