d3thron3d wrote:Soon as someone's like I think we should do the G over the CBA to minor 5th... Fucking shoot that guy.
I guess I'd be dead.
Don't get me wrong, I get what you're saying. If you're writing/jamming a song just go with it, let it flow, don't think about it. But in order to remember what you just played and to play it again, you have to apply language to it afterwards. Be that language music theory like you mentioned or just "that cool thing you did on the 4th fret with the bendy motion." You are not going to remember much without language. And that is all music theory is, a verbal language for music. It's not to complicate things, it is a tool to help you communicate verbally what you are hearing so you can identify it and/or play it again.
However, if some guy without even playing a note waltzes in to practice and is like "HEY WHAT WE'RE GONNA DO TODAY IS PLAY IN THE KEY OF C#HARMONIC MINOR, AND WE'RE GONNA DO SOME SHIFTY SWITCHING BETWEEN THE MAJOR/MINOR SEVENTHS, AND WE GOTTA DO ONE KEY CHANGE TO B MINOR THEN BACK TO C#, GOT IT? HIT IT DUDES."
Fuck that guy. Play music, apply the language later so you can play that music again. Starting with language is not a good idea when making interesting music.