The Wood Wizard wrote:Make the "quiet" parts really loud, and make the heavy parts EVEN LOUDER. Tis the DOOm way my friend.
+1 my band does a lot of switching between cleaner atmosphere and crushing doom...it varies a lot from room to room but that's one of the stepping stones on the path of any performing musician, adjusting your rig to work well in different rooms.
The fault in the whole "prog wont work in a cathedral" example is that there are a multitude of bands that play more than just one genre of music so in theory the only room that would work for them would be a room that automatically changes its size depending on the tonal variations.
Someone asked a while back why a Master Vol head is different than one without and the benefits. This exact situation is one of them, keep your Gain knob set at the appropriate dist break up and attenuate the overall volume to match the room with the Master. Also usually if you are going to be playing a large venue that your half or full stack is not loud enough to project evenly into all corners of the room, this is usually where everything is miced into the house system(hopefully with an engineer that knows a thing or two bout a thing or two)
I was recently toying with the idea of possibly creating a rack EQ chain/device(if not already possible with devices that exist) that would do a pink noise test on the guitar amp(instead of PA) to EQ the individual rig to the room...don't know if that would work, make much of a difference, or be practical at all...but its a thought.
Graves at Sea fucking rule, ideal setting for doom i've found is something like a 24x36 room...just big enough to let then crushingness breath, just small enough to create some pressure and air flow in the room...but in all honesty...im not sure it was the room or the dynamics/structure of Graves at Sea that was throwing it off...I know it's hard for most doom fans to believe(myself included), but those people probably just weren't into it.
I think there might have been something mental about your vocalist, I do guitar/vox and take Sleep style super volume straight down to jazz club level outros and people seem to fucking love it...in fact when there is nothing else for someone to like within our music...they usually compliment how rad it is weaving from intense high volume super energy into low volume atsmospheric spellbinding.