Unpopular album opinions

Your band, other bands, singers, songwriters, more.

Moderator: Ghost Hip

Post Reply
User avatar
DarkAxel
IAMILFFAMOUS
IAMILFFAMOUS
Posts: 8726
Joined: Mon Sep 27, 2010 1:38 pm
Location: BWARRRRM

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by DarkAxel »

D.o.S. wrote:
DarkAxel wrote:post-reunion Swans discography is overall better than pre-breakup

Especially talking about consistency. BIG TIME
If by that you mean they've more or less made the same good record three times over, I agree.

SwAC/DC is pretty nice.
That's not fair, My Father... seems much closer to the mid-to-late-career stuff because it's much more "songy", it's really The Seer and To Be Kind that do have a common aesthetic lets say :idk:

I dare you to find older Swans albums that would be as good front to back AND album to album. Except for Soundtracks for the Blind which are phenomenal but totally unprecedented, too.
I make pedal demos as East Stomp Boutique - http://www.youtube.com/c/eaststompboutique

great deals: Jwar Kayzer Bellyheart wfs1234 bronzetalon Ech0 Scruffie MaxMaps solarolosonoio Schlatte WeHuntKings Monkeydancer Eric! Univalve Huggernaut fuzzmax amorphous Tristan Goroth dan_abnormal Obulus Jrmy BitchPudding beezlebub ianmarks darkfield Abanoise Jskadiang Disarm D'Arcy Snufkino Gerb somethingclever fidget
Top
User avatar
D.o.S.
IAMILFFAMOUS
IAMILFFAMOUS
Posts: 29881
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2011 8:47 am
Location: Ewe-Kay

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by D.o.S. »

If you tuned into the live shows around that time you'd find that the MF.... material was already developing into stuff that sounds like it should have been off The Seer/TBC. See Gira's commentary about how No Words/No Thoughts should have been longer but he pussied out on record and the 20 minute versions they played on tour (so many bells):
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ITqOqlZTTY[/youtube]

You are right, though, in that it definitely still featured songs that were in an Angels of Light mode (this may be why it's the best record of the three).

But, if you're asking for groupings of records in the Swans discog that are just as good as the three reunion albums as a trilogy, I'd say Greed-Holy Money-Children of God or White Light + Love of Life both qualify.
good deals are here.
flesh couch is here.
UglyCasanova wrote: It's not the expensive programs you use, it's the way you click and drag.
Achtane wrote:
comesect2.0 wrote:Michael Jackson king tut little Richard in your butt.
IT'S THE ENNNND OF THE WORRRLD AS WE KNOW IT
Top
User avatar
Inconuucl
Supporter
Supporter
Posts: 6407
Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2014 9:35 pm
Location: Boston, MA

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by Inconuucl »

But I like all of Love of Life. :idk: Which has been discussed earlier. Amnesia is one of my favorite songs ever.
Le Ciel Inconnu (I was a whale once.)
Image
NSFW: show
Chankgeez wrote: We should have a game show à la Name That Tune

Inconuucl: I can shoegaze that tune with 5 pedals.
other contestant: I can shoegaze that tune with 4 pedals.
Inconuucl: I can shoegaze that tune with 3 pedals.
other contestant: OK, shoegaze that tune!
Inconuucl: :!!!:
Top
User avatar
D.o.S.
IAMILFFAMOUS
IAMILFFAMOUS
Posts: 29881
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2011 8:47 am
Location: Ewe-Kay

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by D.o.S. »

I mean more or less all of the new Swans records are elaborations on themes (musically) that were buried in those two albums, but I feel like most of the Swans dickriding (not that Axel's doing this, just in general) is codified into glorifying the Public Castration-era live reputation and the jam band excesses of the last two records, which leaves a lot of really great music out to pasture because... it isn't cool? or something.

And I say this as someone who's a big fan of the band and likes the reunion records quite a bit.
good deals are here.
flesh couch is here.
UglyCasanova wrote: It's not the expensive programs you use, it's the way you click and drag.
Achtane wrote:
comesect2.0 wrote:Michael Jackson king tut little Richard in your butt.
IT'S THE ENNNND OF THE WORRRLD AS WE KNOW IT
Top
User avatar
DarkAxel
IAMILFFAMOUS
IAMILFFAMOUS
Posts: 8726
Joined: Mon Sep 27, 2010 1:38 pm
Location: BWARRRRM

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by DarkAxel »

I do admit I got into Swans (I got to know OF them even) after The Seer came out. So that was basically my introduction to the band... and it took me a while to stomach but it sort of got under my skin because of how vast and free for interpretation and emotional response this side of them is :idk:

whereas... you know... A LOT of the mid to late era Swans is very "normal", traditional songwriting. Which yes, has more meaning on its own, but it doesn't give you the freedom to interpret it yourself and get lost in the trance of the repetitiveness as much :idk: Yes, there are incredible songs for sure ("Failure" comes to mind) but in general it just seems so tame in its form to me. Too... concrete. That's why I like Soundtracks... so much. Because it's mostly abstract as fuck

Might just need to listen... better you know? :idk: a lot of the normal stuff on MF is awesome. Jim is great and Eden Prison is like the best combo of the normal and the fucked up. That disharmonic climax is one of the most hard-hitting things I've ever heard and I swear every hair on my body shoots straight up when I hear it.
I make pedal demos as East Stomp Boutique - http://www.youtube.com/c/eaststompboutique

great deals: Jwar Kayzer Bellyheart wfs1234 bronzetalon Ech0 Scruffie MaxMaps solarolosonoio Schlatte WeHuntKings Monkeydancer Eric! Univalve Huggernaut fuzzmax amorphous Tristan Goroth dan_abnormal Obulus Jrmy BitchPudding beezlebub ianmarks darkfield Abanoise Jskadiang Disarm D'Arcy Snufkino Gerb somethingclever fidget
Top
User avatar
D.o.S.
IAMILFFAMOUS
IAMILFFAMOUS
Posts: 29881
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2011 8:47 am
Location: Ewe-Kay

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by D.o.S. »

Soundtracks is my favorite record (single-standing) of theirs, actually.

Probably important to contextualize their other records with what was happening at the time.
good deals are here.
flesh couch is here.
UglyCasanova wrote: It's not the expensive programs you use, it's the way you click and drag.
Achtane wrote:
comesect2.0 wrote:Michael Jackson king tut little Richard in your butt.
IT'S THE ENNNND OF THE WORRRLD AS WE KNOW IT
Top
User avatar
DarkAxel
IAMILFFAMOUS
IAMILFFAMOUS
Posts: 8726
Joined: Mon Sep 27, 2010 1:38 pm
Location: BWARRRRM

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by DarkAxel »

I've never been able to do that with any band actually. Probably the reason why I find Beatles pretty boring :lol:
I make pedal demos as East Stomp Boutique - http://www.youtube.com/c/eaststompboutique

great deals: Jwar Kayzer Bellyheart wfs1234 bronzetalon Ech0 Scruffie MaxMaps solarolosonoio Schlatte WeHuntKings Monkeydancer Eric! Univalve Huggernaut fuzzmax amorphous Tristan Goroth dan_abnormal Obulus Jrmy BitchPudding beezlebub ianmarks darkfield Abanoise Jskadiang Disarm D'Arcy Snufkino Gerb somethingclever fidget
Top
User avatar
D.o.S.
IAMILFFAMOUS
IAMILFFAMOUS
Posts: 29881
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2011 8:47 am
Location: Ewe-Kay

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by D.o.S. »

.
good deals are here.
flesh couch is here.
UglyCasanova wrote: It's not the expensive programs you use, it's the way you click and drag.
Achtane wrote:
comesect2.0 wrote:Michael Jackson king tut little Richard in your butt.
IT'S THE ENNNND OF THE WORRRLD AS WE KNOW IT
Top
User avatar
casecandy
IAMILF
IAMILF
Posts: 2905
Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2015 12:44 am

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by casecandy »

D.o.S. wrote:.
This post represents you as a person.
Top
User avatar
D.o.S.
IAMILFFAMOUS
IAMILFFAMOUS
Posts: 29881
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2011 8:47 am
Location: Ewe-Kay

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by D.o.S. »

Dear Diary.

Woke up today. Found out casecandy was still posting.

Today was not a good day, Diary.
good deals are here.
flesh couch is here.
UglyCasanova wrote: It's not the expensive programs you use, it's the way you click and drag.
Achtane wrote:
comesect2.0 wrote:Michael Jackson king tut little Richard in your butt.
IT'S THE ENNNND OF THE WORRRLD AS WE KNOW IT
Top
User avatar
casecandy
IAMILF
IAMILF
Posts: 2905
Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2015 12:44 am

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by casecandy »

D.o.S. wrote:Dear Diary.

Woke up today. Found out casecandy was still posting.

Today was not a good day, Diary.
Aw, you know you love me.
Top
User avatar
Mudfuzz
HERO
HERO
Posts: 16705
Joined: Sat Jul 07, 2007 7:06 pm
Location: The gloomy lands of the northwest

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by Mudfuzz »

as much as I like pre roots Sepultura… their version of Orgasmatron is not as good as the original.
Top
User avatar
Iommic Pope
IAMILFFAMOUS
IAMILFFAMOUS
Posts: 11400
Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 8:41 pm
Location: Frimmin' on the Fram

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by Iommic Pope »

Nah it's cool.
It's not that great.
Biotech is Godzilla is pretty fucking rad, though.
WWPD?
fcknoise wrote:You are all fucking tryhard effort posting nerds
Invisible Man wrote: I'm probably the most humble person I know. I feel good about smelling my own butthole.
Jesus Was a Robot wrote:Did you just assume Billy Corgan's dildo preference??
Top
User avatar
D.o.S.
IAMILFFAMOUS
IAMILFFAMOUS
Posts: 29881
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2011 8:47 am
Location: Ewe-Kay

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by D.o.S. »

Mudfuzz wrote:as much as I like pre roots Sepultura… their version of Orgasmatron is not as good as the original.
The studio one, no. the UAPGS version is the best one going by any band ever.
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U1wxRxs451Q[/youtube]
good deals are here.
flesh couch is here.
UglyCasanova wrote: It's not the expensive programs you use, it's the way you click and drag.
Achtane wrote:
comesect2.0 wrote:Michael Jackson king tut little Richard in your butt.
IT'S THE ENNNND OF THE WORRRLD AS WE KNOW IT
Top
User avatar
flanagan0718
involved
involved
Posts: 89
Joined: Mon Feb 01, 2016 5:03 pm

Re: Unpopular album opinions

Post by flanagan0718 »

For the Post-HC / Post-Punk lovers out there...IMO anything with Anthony Green and/or Jonny Craig in it is highly over rated!
My name is Mike and i sometimes build pedals under Custohmelectronics
Blog- http://custohmelectronics.blogspot.com/
Facebook- https://www.facebook.com/custohmelectronics/?ref=hl
Top
Post Reply

Return to “Music”